this post was inspired by the thoughts of dr. kelly flanagan in a post called, "marriage is for losers." i encourage you to read it--it is relevant and well stated.
i have often thought about equality between relationship partners. in every relationship i have been in, i have considered whether one of us was more dominant than the other. think about the relationships you have had. did one person always make the decisions? did one person always get their way? was there usually a "winner" and a "loser" in fights, arguments, or conversation?
how much do you compromise in a relationship? how much ought you to give up for your partner's sake? i believe it is just as possible to give too much as it is to give too little.
your thoughts, feelings, and opinions are much of what makes up who you are. these things need to be shared VERY OPENLY in relationships. i have seen the effect of poor communication in relationships. in most cases, not sharing an opinion is infinitely worse than sharing one.
now i want to suggest that there is a correlation between relationship equality and compromise. in order to be equal, both partners in a relationship need to share their feelings. there also needs to be a willingness to compromise. sometimes this means that you don't get to eat at your choice of restaurant. sometimes this means that you allow your partner to "win" an argument even when you think he/she is clearly wrong. compromising does not mean that the same person is always compromising--it needs to go both ways. whatever the circumstance, we need to be open enough to consider the other person's point of view. and we should be able to expect that our partner is honestly sharing their point of view. there is no reason for silence.
dr. ben carson taught me a lesson at the BYU devotional on Feb 24th. he told the story of a pair of adult siamese twins. they were very intelligent. both had college degrees. both of them had doctorates (though only one of them had wanted one). in considering the operation to separate them, they were informed that there was a possibility that one or both of them could die. despite the danger, they decided to go ahead. ben quoted them as saying, "we would rather die than spend another day stuck together." dr. carson gave us this response: "i was surprised at first, but then i did something that i highly recommend you try out--i put myself in their shoes." after he considered how difficult it would be to spend literally every second of every day stuck to another person, regardless of how much you liked that person, he decided it would be very difficult indeed.
the point i am trying to make in sharing that story is that we need to put ourselves in our partners shoes. we may think that we know our partner very well, but chances are that you don't know everything. i bet that those siamese twins still had arguments. i bet that they sometimes surprised each other with their differences of opinion. as we interact with our significant others, we need to put ourselves in their shoes often. every time that we disagree. that doesn't mean we will necessarily change our minds, but it does mean we are more likely to understand and to empathize.
in dr. flanagan's blog, he speaks of three different kinds of marriage relationships. the first two are grossly unequal. i quote from his blog:
"In the first kind of marriage, both spouses are competing to win, and it’s a duel to the death. Husbands and wives are armed with a vast arsenal, ranging from fists, to words, to silence. These are the marriages that destroy. Spouses destroy each other, and, in the process, they destroy the peace of their children. In fact, the destruction is so complete that research tells us it is better for children to have divorced parents than warring parents. These marriages account for most of the fifty percent of marriages that fail, and then some."
"The second kind of marriage is ripe with winning and losing, but the roles are set, and the loser is always the same spouse. These are the truly abusive marriages, the ones in which one spouse dominates, the other submits, and in the process, both husband and wife are stripped of their dignity. These are the marriages of addicts and enablers, tyrants and slaves, and they may be the saddest marriages of all."
"But there is a third kind of marriage. The third kind of marriage is not perfect, not even close. But a decision has been made, and two people have decided to love each other to the limit, and to sacrifice the most important thing of all—themselves. In these marriages, losing becomes a way of life, a competition to see who can listen to, care for, serve, forgive, and accept the other the most. The marriage becomes a competition to see who can change in ways that are most healing to the other, to see who can give of themselves in ways that most increase the dignity and strength of the other. These marriages form people who can be small and humble and merciful and loving and peaceful."
after reading his words, i came to the conclusion that i need to work to have that third type of marriage in my future. the others are too painful and sad to consider. so how do we create that kind of self-sacrificing, loving, compromising relationship? and how do we do it without changing too much of ourselves?
i believe it is possible to change and compromise in a healthy way and in a healthy quantity. i think there are two main things that we can do to foster equality in our relationships:
1) listen to each other. try to listen more than you talk. when your partner is not speaking, listen more. as you listen, put on his/her shoes.
2) do not be silent. share your opinions, both big and small. there is no reason why a mother-in-law should hear the true feelings of a husband or wife before it has been shared with their partner.
i think there is too much of a tendency for one person in a relationship to dominate the relationship. that dominant person calls all the shots, makes all the plans, and ends up in control. at first there may be a reason why their partner puts up with it. maybe they are just glad to have a boyfriend/girlfriend (or husband/wife). maybe they don't like making choices or they have a hard time choosing between alternatives. but i don't think it is good for a relationship to be so one-sided. in most cases we will make better decisions when two people come together and deliberate. even if our decision is not the best (in our opinion) we may find that joint-solutions are more effective than a solution decided upon without mutual agreement.
i want a relationship where my opinion is equal to (not superior to) my wife's. i want a relationship where my wife feels comfortable calling me an idiot when i am acting like one. i want a relationship where we are both willing to admit it when we are at fault. what do you want? share your thoughts.
Showing posts with label dating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dating. Show all posts
Friday, March 16, 2012
equality in relationships
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
can men and women be just friends?
on december 1st, two guys at USU made a video entitled "why men and women can't be friends." the video starts with interviews of many girls on USU campus. asking them if they think it is possible to be "just friends" with a guy. they all say yes. not only do they say yes, but they mean it! they answer without hesitation and with certainty.
as i watched the video, i thought, 'that's interesting, i don't agree with these girls at all.' then they switch it up and ask a bunch of guys the same question. some of them are ashamed to admit it, while some admit it outright, but they all say no. the consensus among the guys is quite clear: men and women cannot be "just friends."
the final section of the video goes back to the girls that were first interviewed. the interviewer asks each girl if she has a guy who she is "just friends" with. the girls respond: dave, trevor, and so forth. all of them have at least one guy friend that they can think of. then the girls are asked if that guy is interested in them.
this highlights how girls think differently than guys. the girls are aware that the guys are interested in them. some of the girls even say that the guy would be very willing to "hook up" with them if they allowed it. the strange thing is, they don't see this as an issue influencing their friendship. on the one hand you have the guys, who tend to develop crushes with these girls they spend time with, and on the other hand you have the girls, who think that there is no problem with being "just friends" with a guy, regardless of that guys feelings for her.
thus we have "the friend zone."
example (from the video):
"would he hook up with you if you wanted to hook up?"
"yeah."
"so he likes you."
"mhmm."
"so what you're saying is men and women can't be friends."
"no. we can be friends."
"so you're just friends, but he likes you."
"...yes."
"so it's a one-sided friendship."
some girls may have no problem with this scenario. but friendship involves openness and honesty. it also involves giving and receiving. in a "friendship" where one member wants to give and receive more than the other, we would have to admit that the friendship is unequal and flawed. if you imagine, most of these kind of friendships are not very open. a guy who likes a girl but sees that she doesn't feel similarly is relegated to the "friend zone" out of necessity. he has few options. either he continues to be "just friends" with her, therefore allowing him to continue to enjoy her company, or he confesses to her his feelings, therefore changing the nature of the relationship, and potentially losing the friendship all together. what kind of friendship is it, where both parties cannot share their feelings without fear of compromising the friendship?
this scenario can also apply to girls who like guys who do not feel similarly. however, girls are more likely than guys to be content with having "just friends" relationships.
the video ends with the interviewer talking to the camera: "as we can see after interviewing everyone in the library, it is impossible for men and women to be just friends. And under no circumstances can it happen."
although i find the premise of the video fascinating, thought-provoking, and largely accurate, i do not agree with this conclusion. when talking about relationships, there is never cut and dry rules for every situation. when considering myself, i have many female friends that i am legitimately "just friends" with. most of them are married or otherwise taken, which honestly wouldn't debunk the conclusion. however, i am additionally friends with many girls that i know from my childhood and high school days that i am friends with. i can think of several circumstances in which being "just friends" is quite possible. in an effort to be more accurate, i would rephrase the conclusion to say, "in situations where a man sees a woman as a viable partner, it is impossible for him to be content being 'just friends' with her." maybe still partially inaccurate, but it is a good start.
i attached the video below if you want to watch it. and as always, share your thoughts and opinions below.
as i watched the video, i thought, 'that's interesting, i don't agree with these girls at all.' then they switch it up and ask a bunch of guys the same question. some of them are ashamed to admit it, while some admit it outright, but they all say no. the consensus among the guys is quite clear: men and women cannot be "just friends."
the final section of the video goes back to the girls that were first interviewed. the interviewer asks each girl if she has a guy who she is "just friends" with. the girls respond: dave, trevor, and so forth. all of them have at least one guy friend that they can think of. then the girls are asked if that guy is interested in them.
this highlights how girls think differently than guys. the girls are aware that the guys are interested in them. some of the girls even say that the guy would be very willing to "hook up" with them if they allowed it. the strange thing is, they don't see this as an issue influencing their friendship. on the one hand you have the guys, who tend to develop crushes with these girls they spend time with, and on the other hand you have the girls, who think that there is no problem with being "just friends" with a guy, regardless of that guys feelings for her.
thus we have "the friend zone."
example (from the video):
"would he hook up with you if you wanted to hook up?"
"yeah."
"so he likes you."
"mhmm."
"so what you're saying is men and women can't be friends."
"no. we can be friends."
"so you're just friends, but he likes you."
"...yes."
"so it's a one-sided friendship."
some girls may have no problem with this scenario. but friendship involves openness and honesty. it also involves giving and receiving. in a "friendship" where one member wants to give and receive more than the other, we would have to admit that the friendship is unequal and flawed. if you imagine, most of these kind of friendships are not very open. a guy who likes a girl but sees that she doesn't feel similarly is relegated to the "friend zone" out of necessity. he has few options. either he continues to be "just friends" with her, therefore allowing him to continue to enjoy her company, or he confesses to her his feelings, therefore changing the nature of the relationship, and potentially losing the friendship all together. what kind of friendship is it, where both parties cannot share their feelings without fear of compromising the friendship?
this scenario can also apply to girls who like guys who do not feel similarly. however, girls are more likely than guys to be content with having "just friends" relationships.
the video ends with the interviewer talking to the camera: "as we can see after interviewing everyone in the library, it is impossible for men and women to be just friends. And under no circumstances can it happen."
although i find the premise of the video fascinating, thought-provoking, and largely accurate, i do not agree with this conclusion. when talking about relationships, there is never cut and dry rules for every situation. when considering myself, i have many female friends that i am legitimately "just friends" with. most of them are married or otherwise taken, which honestly wouldn't debunk the conclusion. however, i am additionally friends with many girls that i know from my childhood and high school days that i am friends with. i can think of several circumstances in which being "just friends" is quite possible. in an effort to be more accurate, i would rephrase the conclusion to say, "in situations where a man sees a woman as a viable partner, it is impossible for him to be content being 'just friends' with her." maybe still partially inaccurate, but it is a good start.
i attached the video below if you want to watch it. and as always, share your thoughts and opinions below.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
questionnaire
what is most interesting?
based on traffic to my blog, there are some things that my readers tend to find more interesting than others. this is not surprising. also, i tend to be nearly equally interested in thousands of topics, so i want to write about things that you find interesting. solution: this questionnaire
that took like 45 seconds. easy, right? thanks for doing that.
based on traffic to my blog, there are some things that my readers tend to find more interesting than others. this is not surprising. also, i tend to be nearly equally interested in thousands of topics, so i want to write about things that you find interesting. solution: this questionnaire
that took like 45 seconds. easy, right? thanks for doing that.
now a few thoughts and an anecdote before i depart.
i was talking to some friends the other day, and i was complaining about how it is difficult for a guy to let a girl know that he likes her. if a girl likes a guy, the worst she gets in return is, 'oh sorry, i don't like you like that.' which can hurt a lot, but at least it is straightforward and honest, and she can move on. but when a guy likes a girl and she doesn't like him... that is a different story. some girls give all kinds of excuses why they can't go out with a guy, or they just complain about the guy to their friends and call him a creeper. i never understood that. i mean, i understand that guys can be creepy, but i never understood how a guy who genuinely cares about a girl gets labeled as a creeper. my friend gave a fitting anecdote:
i was talking to some friends the other day, and i was complaining about how it is difficult for a guy to let a girl know that he likes her. if a girl likes a guy, the worst she gets in return is, 'oh sorry, i don't like you like that.' which can hurt a lot, but at least it is straightforward and honest, and she can move on. but when a guy likes a girl and she doesn't like him... that is a different story. some girls give all kinds of excuses why they can't go out with a guy, or they just complain about the guy to their friends and call him a creeper. i never understood that. i mean, i understand that guys can be creepy, but i never understood how a guy who genuinely cares about a girl gets labeled as a creeper. my friend gave a fitting anecdote:
i don't know the girl's name, so i will call her suzie. suzie had two prospective suitors. she was really interested in one and not at all interested in the other. since she was aware of their interest, she would often talk about how much she liked the first boy, and how great he was. she would complain about the other boy to her friends and called him a creeper. the interesting thing was, the two boys showed their interest in her by doing the very same things. they would both write suzie notes, ask her on dates, come over to her place and talk to her, and basically let her know that they were thinking of her. the two boys were not consulting with each other, they just did what they thought was best to let suzie know that they were interested. they boys were not very different, the difference lay in her opinion of them. the first boy could do no wrong. anything he did for suzie was appreciated and praised. suzie was so happy whenever he contacted her. but the other boy, despite all of his affectionate gestures, was a creeper. none of his actions meant anything to her. and the worst part is, she didn't even realize the similarity between the two boys. her preconceptions of the situation blinded her to considering them equally.
i'm not trying to blame suzie, i just think it is interesting. there is a fine line between being exactly what a girl wants, and being a creeper. i guess there are similar difficulties girls face. there is also a fine line between getting out there and showing that you are available, and looking desperate.
as usual, i don't have the solutions. but i hope i have given you something to think about.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)